Explain the problem as you see it
The app lacks robust data portability features, making it difficult to ensure long-term access to accumulated knowledge. Current export options are limited to manual Markdown exports or a single JSON file, which don't provide an easily accessible or future-proof solution.
Why is this a problem for you?
- Data lock-in: Risk of losing access to years of knowledge if service becomes unavailable.
- Time-consuming exports: Manual exports are impractical for maintaining an up-to-date archive.
- Limited portability: Current formats don't preserve all metadata and relationships.
- Future accessibility concerns: Difficulty in retrieving specific old information.
- Lack of data ownership: Users don't have full control over their data.
- Hindered workflow evolution: Difficulty in transferring data to new systems as work methods change.
- Compliance issues: Challenges in meeting data retention and backup requirements.
Suggest a solution
- Automated, scheduled exports
- Comprehensive export formats preserving all data and relationships
- Selective exports for specific projects or date ranges
- Full-featured API for custom integrations and backups
- Import capabilities for data migration and restoration
- Export preview and verification features
- Clear documentation on data structures for long-term usability
1 Comment
I think targeting a reasonably open standard (like Obsidian-flavored Markdown or LogSeq-flavored Markdown) might make sense.
Especially when paired with the ability to setup a regular backup schedule to be sent to an offsite location like Dropbox, Google Drive, or S3 (of the user’s choosing).
LogSeq in particular is open source and an outliner, like Tana. If the backup were to omit any Tana-specific nodes like search nodes, perhaps it’ll be good enough to retain at least the raw data in outliner form where the nodes’ bidirectional links are preserved.
Obsidian-compatible Markdown files where each top-level node is a Markdown file and children are bullets, could work too. Referenced nodes become block references, and inline references become [[wikilinks]], and search nodes stripped out.
I could live with either of those for data portability.
For images, the relative links should be preserved and all media should be exported to a folder. Obsidian should be able to handle this. I’m unsure about LogSeq, but there should be a way they handle images too.