We have released our Voice Memos.
We are looking for feedback and first impressions. Please add any feedback on in the thread below.
This feedback will be considered by the product team for our first round of updates in the coming weeks.
Please note, this is not a place for submitting bugs. If you are encountering a bug, please file a report in app via 'submit a bug' in the bottom left settings menu in your Tana workspace.
14 Comments
Awesome!
Pls need Ukarinan language! Будь-ласка, додайте українську!!!!
Whilst I'm loving the new Voice Memos from Tana Capture and their potential, I'm less keen on the tone of the produced article and summary. For example, my summary begins with "Hello" and ends with "Regards" which is totally inappropriate. Will there be a way to moderate the language to suit the user in the way ChatGPT uses its "remember" feature? I have trained it to use my writing style. Thanks for the work, Tana Team.
The feature correctly Tags people on the transcription, but not in the corresponding task
I love the new Voice feature. BUT it seems to have stopped working for me. My voice notes are going to the Inbox again and not into my #day. I don't know whether something has reset - but I cannot find where to look.
Can you tell me where to check before I report a bug??
I work mainly from my desktop, and when I'm in a groove I don't want to go from keyboard to phone to make a voice memo. I would love to see Voice Memo enabled as a command / keyboard shortcut.
Edit: nevermind, it is a keyboard command already! The Help article https://tana.inc/docs/voice-memo only mentions Tana Capture. My feedback now is to clarify both methods in the documentation.
Here are 3 attempts to create a Task using voice notes in Tana Capture for "Fertilize the grass today":
Would be cool to see specific prompts behind the rewrite commands and be able to modify them.
Also add my own rewrite commands and deactivate the ones that I never use (like tweet)
More customizability here generally would be welcome, even necessary, in my opinion. The functionality of memos seems more 'all or nothing' than the typical Tana feature.
Is there a way to configure that voice memos are assigned a certain supertag?
To me, this is important so that I can set up my own workflow about how (and when) to process them - and not depend on remembering to pick up untagged nodes on the day node. (This is against the Tana philosophy in my opinion).
This could be done when they are processed in the Inbox and moved to the day page.
I am going to set it up so that I can associate it with a project or a content source (like a book, video, podcast) and then queue it to be fully processed in the right context at the relevant time.
Also, it would be great to be able to see/modify what supertag to use for the assigned tasks.
And the output from task assignments are quite hit-and-miss as it is now. It would be good to be able to modify the prompt. And/or perhaps to be able to control it better if task assignments are to be done at all.
Far from all transcripts are business meetings. (In my case, 0% of them).
I use memos mostly to relay thoughts, ideas and insights. For example, while I am listening to a podcast or audio book on the go. These will later go in my PKM or in my ideas for content writing.
It is not a problem that the system extracts potential actions (I would just love to be able to prompt in more variants).
(For some of my insight memos, in the future I may prompt it for ideas for writing topics or content pieces. For example, by comparing it to my past writing work. Additions or augmentations.)
BUT as it is now, I end up with mostly "junk" in the task assignments. So I keep that as a "dead" supertag and then I may assign my real action tag if any of it is relevant.
It is OK to have a supertag as "inbox for potential tasks" but if this begins to work better (read: so that I actually begin to use the feature) I will look to adapt that supertag in a way so that I get command buttons to assign/route the item to where I want. Perhaps not on the #task supertag, but on the #voicememo supertag that I plan to make for my processing.
Question: is it by design that the "Rewrite" button on a voice memo is only visible when the node is shown in a separate panel? (Like, in the inbox). When it is moved to my day page, this button/menu is no longer visible when I expand the node.
First time user, still finding my way.
Voice memos are one of my main reasons for signing up and I used them to record a multi person conversation for the first time yesterday. It picked up my Geordie english accent as being spoken Welsh language. There is a similar cadence to the Geordie and Welsh accents so I can see how this happened.
AI chat suggested I change language settings in Capture , there are no obvious ways to access settings in the app.
Is it possible to change language recognition settings in capture or in Tana desktop ?
Hmm this might not just be you! My latest capture has come out in Welsh (and I sound nothing like Welsh!!)
Yes you can set it via command line. Command-k, and then type 'Set default transcription language' and then select from the options
Didn’t know that - and there is an excellent collection of languages.
But on my Tana English isn’t an option- can this be added??
Discovered you can just type English, rather than accept the suggested languages - which worked.